Beginning this year, with our Youth Council members, we will be discussing one book each month. We already have four books picked out for the first few months of 2026. You will see them here. And it’s exciting to begin with Saadia Faruqi’s latest book, Ms. Marvel Remnants of the Past, that tells the story of Kamala Khan, a superhero with Pakistani-American heritage. This book was released on January 6 in the US.
Note: this review was written by Upasna Kakroo for Peerbagh and has no spoilers.
Wondering which books to read?
Find them in Bento!
Ms. Marvel Remnants of the Past by Saadia Faruqi
The Marvel Universe is the largest comic book enterprise in the United States, with about 40% of the market share, earning nearly 1 billion a year. About 60% of the audience in the US is reportedly in the 18-29 year age group, and there’s a 60:40 split by gender, led by men. Globally, comic book readers in APAC are a highly valuable reader base with strong growth. While the 1930s were hailed as the golden age, there is renewed interest in comics and superhero books with Marvel/Disney movies and their digital presence. So, even if you did not read the comic Ms. Marvel (featuring Kamala Khan) in 2014, you probably heard about the movie that was released in 2022.
Kamala Khan was first introduced as a character in 2013, the first Pakistani-American Marvel superhero living in New Jersey, credited to Sana Amanat (a comic creator who shares the heritage). The comic books (five volumes) were created by G. Willow Wilson (writer) and Adrian Alphona (illustrator). While Marvel has long been criticized for racial representation, this was seen as a step forward. As the first South-Asian and Muslim woman superhero, Ms. Marvel comics were well received. So, it was a surprise (a pleasant one) when Saadia Faruqi announced last year that she was writing a Young Adult Ms. Marvel book.
What works in the new Ms. Marvel
With Faruqi’s prolific writing career and lived experiences as a Pakistani-American immigrant, this is a match made in heaven. She brings in all her favorite writing devices to transport readers – from mouth-watering desi foods, her ability to draw nuanced portrayals of people who show their faith in many different ways, including the one annoying (side character) brother, to the best writing transitions. It’s a treat if you’re an emerging writer to see how masterfully Faruqi captures imagination and builds on the worldview of an existing comic character.
The writing is light and fun, and if you’ve read Saadia’s books before, you will recognize her characteristic wit and humor. The most fun part is the cinematic brush strokes with which Ms. Marvel captures both Lahore and Jersey City. There’s a lot to unpack as Faruqi breaks down one stereotype after another – from people to disparity in cities, a gaze into the third world, to how we have more in common than not. And finally, an attempt to address the complexities that plague the remnants of our colonial past.
The Dad character is an interesting phenomenon throughout the book. While it may appear that he’s a typical desi dad (overeating puris), concerned about grades, Faruqi gives us a full picture. We get a backstory, as nostalgia and place-specific memories are centered in Lahore. It allows the Dad to have vulnerable moments, rather than adhere to the cardboard Amrish Puri characterization of immigrant dads. And we’re all for humanizing parents! Among other side characters, the friend in Lahore, Maleeha is well written. She has the agency that we need to see more from Desi girls, especially with all the ideas people have about the subcontinent.
Our Historical Patience and Future Wishes
The mother feels a little too lesson-forward (we need impatient mums too!) and may benefit from a sequel. In any case, it would be fair to ask for a Karachi sequel (necessary spoiler: speaking for all up in arms for the mum’s city).
Readers also get a quick snapshot of Mughal history, with the artifacts being central plot drivers. The moment about Aurangzeb’s legacy feels glossed over because people were not upset with his inability to share jobs. He rampaged over non-Muslim populations and even killed his own brother, who was a much stronger supporter of the arts. Who knows where we would have been if Dara Shikoh had been the king of Hindustan? This feels critical because there’s a whole anti-Aurangzeb lobby in the subcontinent. And denying his harshness makes the more extreme powers stronger. We have had prominent bad actors, and it’s not because of their religion but based on how they chose to act out of avarice (as Sheikh Abdullah would say). And while it may feel like it’s our heritage, we inherit both the good and the bad parts of it. This will likely not stand out to the average American reader, but it’s important to a more aware desi population.
The other big idea in the book is about colonial loot, and it’s incredible that this hasn’t been written about more in other books. We need to ask these tough questions of ourselves, in fiction and IRL. Irrespective of how good or bad our subcontinent rulers were, nothing can justify the rampant loot and displacement that the colonial powers created. Asraar’s (another well-drafted character) anger feels justified, but like most hard things superheroes deal with, the question of what belongs to whom feels more complex when the details are laid out.
There is a part in the book where Kamala asks her Fahad Uncle if he’d give up his memories to live longer. And he replies, “No, I wouldn’t. Who… doesn’t want to live? But…not at the cost of…all the years I’ve already…lived.” And maybe that’s what makes the book.
If Marvel wanted to reach demographics outside of its current audience, then the job is done (incredibly at that). A real superhero who speaks our language and goes through our Urdu bazaars is special. All the real magic comes at a cost but is worth the wait and the effort.
Would we recommend: YES! and while you’re at it, please make sure to read the Strongest Heart. It’s Saadia’s best book (as per our subjective opinion).

If you’d like to know the origin story after you finish reading Ms. Marvel Remnants of the Past, pick up 2014 comic, Ms. Marvel (Vol 1). We will be discussing this book in our Youth Council Member meeting on January 24th. If you’re reading it too, share your thoughts with us!
For authors or publishers who would like to submit books for review, please share them on our review form here.










2 responses to “Book of the Month: Ms. Marvel Remnants of the Past by Saadia Faruqi”
Saadia is joining us in Jersey City this weekend for some book events. Your review and commentary is so precise, helpful, and nuanced. Thank you so much for this post.
Saadia is a wonderful writer to host! We hope to enjoy discussing the book with her.